‘Switzerland is a free country; here it is easy to introduce new ideas.’
Scriabin to Y. Engel
Scriabin travelled considerably more widely than some of his compatriots, especially when the shortness of his life (1872–1915) is taken into account. His first significant trips abroad were to France and Germany for concert-giving. Later in life he had two relatively short but significant periods of residence in Geneva: February to November 1904 and January to September 1906. What drew this unique musician to the illustrious city, not once, but twice?
We should first consider the way that intellectual Russians, ‘dissidents’ as we would say now, Nihilists, Socialists and Communists in those days as well as ‘terrorists’ – a term the use of which may depend on the speaker’s point of view – how they regarded Switzerland, and why. Russia was then and is now an autonomously ruled country of severe restrictions on the expression of thought and on individual mores. Scriabin was no nihilist or terrorist, though it was during his first times in Geneva that he developed strong Socialistic interests. In the haunts of working-class people, cafés and the like, he was able to find enthusiastic listeners for an elementary Socialist gospel: there should be no money, no unemployment, no beggars, each should work as he likes. He experimented with “preaching” his ideas from a boat and derived a Tolstoyan pleasure from making friends among the fishermen, particularly one, an older character named Otto, whose views of Scriabin’s own music were enthusiastic but unsurprisingly not those of an educated man: “What a lot of noise Sasha makes all by himself.”
Some of these principles, which we find also in the Socialism of William Morris in England, were certainly derived from the Social Contract (1762) of the Geneva-based philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau. The Swiss background from which Rousseau sprang was the opposite of the Russian: strongly democratic, with a historically based system of direct representation, and broadly liberal in outlook, famously neutral in stance. A little later than the period of Scriabin’s residence in Geneva, the mystical writer to whom he was most devoted, Mme Blavatsky, was banned by Russian censorship in 1908. Scriabin had “discovered” her writing and theories in Vesenaz, on the fringes of Geneva, in 1904–5. Tolstoy’s radical religious book What I believe in would not have interested Scriabin – it proposed a radical form of Christianity – but this too had been banned in 1884 and was smuggled into Russia from Switzerland, where it was published. These acts of censorship stand as reminders, if such were needed, of the merciless stranglehold of the Russian autocracy – which, contrary to its intended outcome, helped to create the social pressures which inevitably burst through in the Revolution of 1917. Lenin was in Zurich at the period before the Revolution; in his novel depicting the period, Solzhenitsyn satirises Lenin’s fallibility as a prophet by having him speculate how “ripe for revolution” Swiss society allegedly was.
The lacustrine atmosphere must have encouraged what English Victorians would have termed “free thinking”. Sitting by Lake Geneva, at the lovely resort of Belotte, during summer 1904, Scriabin filled a blue notebook with considerations on the nature of consciousness and experience, the first of a series of private journals in which he hammered out the beginnings of a ‘world-view’ – something that never condensed into a methodical system but always retained a degree of fluidity and indeterminacy. Meanwhile Scriabin wrote to his patron Margarita Morozova about his reading of German idealist philosophers: Fichte, Kant, Schelling and Hegel. In the autumn he attended the International Philosophical Congress. This was the second of its kind and was held in the University of Geneva. That the first conference was in Paris shows the international calibre required of the venue. To a modern reader, the lectures reprinted in the record of the conference are astonishingly idealistic in the majority of cases. This certainly helps to provide a background for Scriabin’s own comprehensive idealism. The pre-First War European and Russian culture was a final flowering of idealism, to be killed off by the coming deluge of mechanised slaughter. If, for example, as in Theodore Flournoy’s ‘panpsychism’, it is ‘admitted’ that ‘our whole universe exists at the level of immaterial, psychical, conscious realities’, a new recruit at the front in 1914 may not have found his study of Flournoy ultimately helpful when he witnesses such an ‘interchange of purely psychical actions and reactions’ as, for example, a bomb or a shell carrying off, with no warning, half the face of the man next to him. Flournoy was born in Switzerland into a thoroughly bourgeois milieu: a stockbroker for a father and a mother whose family were ministers, judges and teachers. He qualified as a doctor, but the fact that he never practised medicine suggests that the family had considerable means. It is not being suggested that any of these things was harmful in itself, but no or little sense of everyday life can have been gained by Flournoy in his studies of psychology with William James, what may be termed theories of the mechanism of perception with Wilhelm Wundt, and educational theory with Alfredo Binet. Scriabin’s poème Flammes sombres (Dark Flames), though, a short dance associated with a piece of verse, part of the Mystery project he was occupied on when he died, shows an empathy with the horror of war and its corrosion of the human spirit rare in those days when realism about war was scarce and the general view was that the conflict that started in 1914 was a glorious cleansing enterprise. One may compare Paul Nash’s horrifying landscape We Are Creating A New World, which for naked realism can itself only be compared with the canvases of Vereshchagin, notably The Apotheosis of War, (1871), a depiction of a vast pyramid of skulls (first exhibited in St Petersburg 1874) which must have been known to Scriabin. Nash and Vereshchagin were disapproved of in their times for showing the truth of war; national and financial interests were all against such realism. The prosperity, cleanliness and pacifism of Switzerland cannot have been lost on Scriabin, whose nature was fastidious, who loved Nature and the open air (as we know from a series of remarkable letters to a beloved of earlier years, Natalia Sekerina) and who was notoriously fussy about the possibility of infections. What was important for his internal development was the idealistic tendency of contemporary philosophy – and the problem of conveying philosophy in music.
The atmosphere of Geneva brought forth a period of great productivity in Scriabin. His lakeside activity in writing philosophical notes was complemented in musical composition, which he considered the best, if not the only way to convey philosophical thought: he finished the vast Third Symphony (Le divin Poème), all but the orchestration, and worked on the Poem of Ecstasy – two works where the philosophical basis is at its most explicit, and has dispensed with Christianity. He considered that in allowing a hand injury and also with the trauma of rejection by his ‘muse,’ Natalia, God had dealt with him over-severely; but it was this rejection of an Orthodoxy accepted unquestioningly since earliest youth that brought Scriabin under the influence of the philosophers he had enumerated to Morozova. A few years later Scriabin composed a poem in verse, which he published himself in Geneva in 1906 as a counterpart to the Poem of Ecstasy. This first attempt at samizdat was partly caused by a quarrel with Scriabin’s existing publishers, who had cut his fees and opened the giving of prizes to other composers, not just Belaieff’s favourite Scriabin; but the dogmatic business-led self-assertion of that great publishing-house, which, moreover, had just lost its leader (Belaieff, Scriabin’s generous, paternalistic patron and mentor, had died in January 1904) was not friendly to such an attempt at self-assertion. The leaflet, though, did not lose as much money as did Scriabin’s self-published Fifth Sonata in 1908. It was an eye-opening experience for him to deal as a self-publisher with distributors and stores who were not interested in building up stocks of unknown, difficult music.
Each of these works: Le Divin Poème, the Fifth Sonata, The Poem of Ecstasy and its literary counterpart, was conceived, developed or finished in Geneva or its environs; and each constituted a major step towards the Mystery, the final, transformative work Scriabin kept in his head. Thus, the Divin Poème introduces the idea of a high mission with a noble “motto-theme” which runs through the work, and the Hindu concept of “divine play” in a newly conceived type of finale, flying and breathless in expression. In the Fifth Sonata a new concept of an upward spiralling form symbolises either successive incarnations or new developments of personality.
Eventually the Fifth Piano Sonata was published by Koussevitzky, marking the beginning of a new business association between conductor/publisher and composer. This significant friendship and partnership began during a visit by Koussevitzky in May 1908 to Lausanne, whither Scriabin had moved in September of 1907.
Swiss marriage laws were somewhat less dogmatic than those in Russia. Scriabin had formed a new relationship with Tatiana Schloezer, and now there was a child, but Scriabin’s first wife, Vera, would never grant a divorce, were that possible (it would have to be granted by the Tsar), and as Scriabin complained, in Russia a marriage certificate was “an admission ticket to Society.” This may have been in Vera Scriabina’s mind too. She had learned independence in a harsh upbringing, but she knew also that at every turn the hand of the law was turned implacably against the woman. She was also aware that in making a living as a pianist in whose repertoire her husband’s works were prominently represented the name she had married into was of great importance. We are told that she played differently from Scriabin, whose fantastical approach and extreme rhythmic freedom she disapproved of; but critical views, especially concerning what we would now think of as ‘stylistic appropriateness’, were much broader at that time, and indeed the concept of an “appropriate style” for a particular period or composer barely existed.
Social views in general were less rigidly applied in Switzerland than in Russia. When Scriabin was first in Geneva, his relationship with the woman with whom he was to spend the rest of his life, Tatiana Schloezer, was in developing stages. Indeed, part of the incentive to foreign travel may have been to establish some distance between himself and the two female angles of this triangle. Scriabin spent some time writing reassuring letters to both women, but his letters to Tatiana are of a unique quality in underlining the close connection between their physical relationship and Scriabin’s creative work (in this case, on the Poem of Ecstasy)
(Geneva, 20th June/3rd July 1905):
Tanyushka, so this time it’s you who are going to be jealous of me! You complain that you can’t find new words of love and caresses, but I have found them, and such words, such caresses!
Next time we meet I shall pronounce them to you, that is to say, I shall play. I have never caressed like this before […]
Tatiana had in fact installed herself not far away in Bogliasco. She had got to know Scriabin properly in 1902, when she was nineteen or twenty. She and her older brother Boris were living in Moscow together. Scriabin got on with them particularly well and Tatiana, with great assurance, expressed her worship of his music, became his pupil; and not very much later, when Scriabin was in Geneva in April 1904, she moved to Belle-Rive, quite near. In this period, between April and June, they became lovers. Where Boris was at this period the chronicles do not specify; but it seems logical that a young unmarried woman needed to be with a chaperone and therefore Boris would continue to live with her wherever she went. He became a useful friend to Scriabin, being a graduate in philosophy. His accounts, in the book he published in 1920, after Sabaneyev’s first but before his Reminiscences, are a useful corrective to Sabaneyev. The author of the Reminiscences was scientifically and mathematically trained and clarified and solidified Scriabin’s thoughts, whereas Schloezer understood that the “philosophy” was not a hard and fast system but, to use an expression Vyacheslav Ivanov borrowed from Goethe, a schwankende Gestalt, an uncertainly wavering figure, which is a deeply Symbolist concept.
It was in Geneva that Scriabin met the sculptor Niederhausen, known as Rodo because he had been Rodin’s assistant. Niederhausen introduced Scriabin to the writing and thought of H. P. Blavatsky. In Geneva, too, Scriabin received some newspaper cuttings, via Tatiana’s dying father, concerning the fact that Modeste Altschuler was inviting Russian composers to come and perform their works in New York. Here was the first hint of Scriabin’s American visit, which was to turn out so unfortunately.
The mystical side of Scriabin’s development in thinking was challenged by his relationship with the Marxist philosopher Georgii Plekhanov, which started in Bogliasco, on the Ligurian coast, Italy and continued thereafter. Plekhanov constantly questioned Scriabin’s idealist assumptions (“I could jump off this bridge and remain motionless in the air.” “Just try it, then, Alexander Nikolaevich!”) and this helped the composer to sort out his socialist aspirations from the spiritual significance he ascribed to his music: “I don’t wish to bring about anything except an enormous impetus in spiritual activities”, he wrote to his patroness Maria Morozova.
Scriabin arrived in Geneva in 1906 for his second period there accompanied by Tatiana, now his permanent partner, and their daughter Ariadna. While we don’t know what effect these travels abroad had on Ariadna, she, along with Scriabin’s son with her Julian, showed the strongest talent of any of the children. Julian drowned as a child at the age of eleven, leaving behind some beautiful and tantalising preludes, but Ariadna survived to write some powerful poetry, to move to France in time for the Nazi occupation with her third husband, who was Jewish (she herself converted to Judaism) and to die fighting for the French Resistance.
On 17/30 June 1906 Scriabin played a solo recital in the Conservatory in Geneva. Having been opened in 1835 it is one of the oldest of such establishments in Europe. It now holds 2,500 students. Courting the Geneva public with his older and more approachable music, Scriabin played his youthful Concert Allegro, the perennially popular Nocturne for the Left Hand, preludes from op.11 and the Third Sonata. The virtuosic Waltz op 38 was a comparative novelty; the radical new Fifth Sonata was not included. Significantly, Scriabin dedicated a proportion of the profits from this concert to ‘liberation movements in Russia’. Ernest Ansermet was present; later, as conductor of L’Orchestre de la Suisse romande, he proved an indefatigable fighter for twentieth-century music.
The following year saw a disastrous and abortive tour to America. Tatiana crossed the Atlantic against Alexander’s advice, and the news of their non-marital relationship created a scandal which necessitated their immediate departure and the cancellation of Scriabin’s concerts. Their arrival in Europe was in Paris from which they returned to Switzerland, this time to Beatenberg and later Lausanne in September, where Scriabin had moved in September of 1907. Scriabin and his partner Tatiana were in financial straits, and Scriabin gave a solo concert of his own works on 1st November, after which he returned to Russia for a while.
Back in Lausanne at the beginning of 1908, Scriabin travelled to Leipzig to make his first recording for player piano, returning in time for the birth of his son Julian. A boy born earlier, Lev, Scriabin’s son with Vera, had died in infancy; the sad fate of Julian, just after the death of Scriabin, had died in infancy. A visit by Koussevitzky in May 1908 to Lausanne marked the beginning of a significant friendship and partnership.
Other musical visitors to Lausanne were the pianist Mark Meichik who studied the Fifth Sonata and later wrote a tiny, but significant book about Scriabin, and the conductor Emil Cooper, who worked on the Third Symphony and the Poem of Ecstasy with Scriabin. In August Scriabin and Tatiana visited Koussevitzky in Biarritz. From there they travelled to Paris, Brussels and Berlin, arriving in St Petersburg at the beginning of 1909. After that Moscow remained their home apart from a short visit to Brussels in 1909–10.
Scriabin brought back with him to Moscow an outstanding example of Swiss art in the shape of a painting by Ferdinand Hodler (1853–1918) – a painting typical of the artist’s output at the turn of the century, which was marked by groups of figures symbolising such subjects as Lake Thun or Day. The presence in the Museum of Scriabin’s acquisition, a group entitled Condemned to Death, very likely bought in Geneva, is a concrete reminder of the importance of Swiss culture in Scriabin’s background and of his lasting affection for the country and its liberal values.