Then all of a sudden the existentialists climbed onto the chairs and started up a football-style chant:
“It-e, it-e, it-ex-ists!”
The student halls kitchen resembled a battlefield. There was tomato sauce everywhere and knives lying about the place, bloodstained and disgusting from the meat. A dweeb in a shabby scarf was lecturing us about how Dubito not only existed but was the most European of all European bars.
“Have you ever actually seen it?” I asked him.
“I don’t have to have seen it in order to draw the logical conclusion.”
A guy who’d already had a lot to drink said Dubito was a pop-up bar. The notion of the pop-up was based on the archetypal Aristotelean automaton— what you needed sprung up just like that as you were walking along, like a Platonic recollection. The more he developed the idea, the more it pleased him. ‘I explain it all so damned well’ was written all over his face. Then he got up and started lecturing to an audience of dried-out spaghetti in an auditorium at the bottom of the cooking pot. I thought of my father, who believed philosophy was an outdated occupation for European cranks that had reached its definitive end with the work of Jurgen Habermas. My PhD seemed to him like a very bad idea. I’d end up talking to myself, he said, like all those other clever women who cohabited with cats and ghosts. Dad, I said, if those women heard you talking about them like that, they’d sic their cats on you.
“So on a random night down a random street in Brussels, a bar just pops up complete with drinks, bar spoons and stools?”
“Only ever down blind alleys,” the dweeb corrected me. He’d never been to Dubito, but he believed in inductive reasoning.
“So it appears down a blind alley and disappears the next morning? And if you pass by you get to go in, but if you don’t then you don’t?”
“In phenomenological terms, Dubito becomes apparent to our perception if we question the self-sufficiency of reason,” said a nerdy Husserlian.
“Are you saying the bar’s an ideal form?”
“I’m saying that consciousness constitutes reality, it’s not subject to it.”
“The point is to see the bar as though for the first time,” threw in the dweeb.
“But you do see it for the first time! You just said it’s a pop-up, and it’s gone right after it appears.”
“You’re pretty far gone yourself, Ms. Spinoza,” said the faux-Godard with the black horn-rimmed spectacles who’d been waging a long-term campaign to get me into bed. It drove him mad that I could never remember whether his name was Jacques or Jean and called him Jean-Jacques.
The guy next to him fixed me with the empty stare of a cow. Cows graze on grass, phenomenologists graze on experiences. They’re cuckoo—they believe the mind, as a logical system, determines its content. So what business would a phenomenologist have in Dubito, supposing the bar actually to exist at all? They’d never question their cognisance of it, they’d rather it just remained outside their awareness altogether.
They called me “Ms. Spinoza” as a put-down. They’d rather have had a romantic, neo-platonic girl to hang around with and impress. I turned to the sceptics in the room, the Descartes fans. They’d formed a huddle and were speaking loudly over one other as though in the middle of a blazing row. There was only one thing they could all agree on: that the profile of Descartes, with the big nose, drooping eyelids and dubious fringe, was featured all over Dubito. It appeared on the paper towels, the beer mats and the glasses. The description reeked of urban myth.
“Who gave him that crap haircut?” wondered a guy, slurring from the whisky he’d drunk. With every move he made he spilt a little more of his drink onto the beige leather upholstery of the kitchen couch. Once more my father came to mind, cursing ‘philosopher drunks’. I shook my head to dispel the image. The existentialists thought I was still arguing with them, and started chanting again:
“It-e, it-e, it-ex-ists!”
The Cartesians were more easy-going. They expressed their loyalty to the team by means of imitation – Jules, for example, sported a badly cut fringe like Descartes, and the same Cervantesian whiskers. I distrusted the lot of them. Collective obsessions make for collective delusions. Philosophers live in their theories as users live in their dope. I left them yapping and went up to my room. I swore never to sleep with any of them. I’d carry on dating waiters and workers only, ordinary straightforward types with nothing to prove beyond the definition of their abs.
The exam period was approaching. Coming home from the library one evening, I cut through the Rue des Bouchers and found myself at the Impasse de la Fidélité.
At the entrance to the blind alley, bathed in the light of lamps I’d never seen before, an art-deco entranceway protruded from between darkened houses. Black and cavernous like the mouth of a beast, it was crowned with Gothic-style lettering that spelt out the word Dubito. My heart skipped. I paced back and forth for a while, as though waiting for someone who wasn’t coming, then pushed the door open and went in.
The room was oval-shaped and dark inside. Candles dripped onto candlesticks. “It looks like the interior of an egg,” I whispered in a language that I didn’t recognise, even though I was the one speaking it. “It doesn’t look like it, it is,” responded the waiter in the same language. “The Night, stirred by the Wind, gave birth to the Egg. That’s us.”
“Who are you, and what language are you speaking?”
“We’re us, and we’re speaking Proto-Indo-European.”
I accepted the explanation. Everything around us looked normal and as it should. The bar, also oval-shaped, divided the room in two. On one side was a barwoman with a black fringe, absorbed in her work. On the other sat the clientele, hunched over their drinks. There was no space at the bar. The waiter encouraged me to order and wait. He said Immanuel Kant would be leaving at exactly ten o’clock, and pointed to a little man wearing a white wig and a long overcoat with knee-length socks and buckled shoes visible beneath. I took up position behind him, slowly sipping my soda. A white hair hung low down on his back. I picked it off surreptitiously and wrapped it round my finger.
“Of what reality are you seeking proof?” he said, without turning to look at me.
“Your existence?”
“Is that a question? You ask if I exist? And you find that the answer lies in a white hair that is not mine, but a part of my wig?”
“Well, I know my mind synthesises my experience, and there can be no experience outside of time,” I said, in an attempt to flatter him.
Kant shook his head, displeased, and got up to leave. I would have to try and pretend to be both intelligent and a little stupid at the same time, as though I already knew everything but was an absolute beginner at the same time.
“I agree with you, though,” said a voice from the next stool. It belonged to a man with a long thin face who was drinking coffee out of a large cup. “We should perceive life not as a problem, but as a reality. As our own reality.”
“Søren,” whispered the guy next to him, slapping him gently on the back, “our true self is there.” He pointed up at the ceiling. “Identify with God, and see everything through your own eyes.”
“Have another?” the barwoman asked me, the moment I’d taken up position on the stool. I ordered another soda. I wasn’t sure she’d heard. She was wiping down the area in front of me with hypnotic motions, tracing wet circles with a cloth.
“Well well, a philosopher who doesn’t drink,” she remarked finally, whereupon she turned out not to be a barwoman after all, but Rene Descartes himself. The fringe and the long hair had deceived me— he’d shaved off the beard as well.
“I know,” said Descartes, placing a stained ‘Dubito’ beer mat in front of me. “Sometimes people mistake me for Simone, we’ve got that same melancholic look.” And he jerked his chin toward a woman in a woollen cloak and round glasses sitting at the other end of the bar. I stared and stared: Simone Weil, right there in front of me! Motionless and frozen, as in a photograph.
“Do you want to find out what she’s drinking?”
“I already know. Tea with no sugar. Because there are people going hungry.”
There was no music in Dubito. The whispering of the company formed an ambient hum, as though someone had released all the crickets that ever existed in the world in there to chirrup at once. Even the silence of the quiet ones had a noise level all of its own, just like that great dark nothingness I encountered whenever I crossed the Grand-Place on my way home from the library late at night. If Europe was not just a construction, a mere advertisement for the free movement of persons and goods, then its heart still beat there in that deserted square, where the merchants of the Middle Ages, the Habsburgs, the troops of Louis XIV, and perhaps even Napoleon himself had trod.
I closed my eyes and took in the sound as though it was a programme that someone else had chosen for me. Just like in the kitchen of our house in Athens, where my father used to cook and listen to radio dramas on the Third Programme whilst I drew – I didn’t know how to read and write back then.
“Hume was right when he said the passions drive human behaviour.”
“Of course. Reason is – ought to be – the slave of the passions.”
“Passions in the sense of deep feelings?”
“What else? Personally, I exclude addiction. That’s the avoidance of true passion.”
“Might we paraphrase Descartes, and say I feel therefore I am?”
Who was asking? Who was answering? The desire which had driven me to study philosophy had been reawakened. The raging desire to be anyone other than myself.
“I know the wise man is the one who is satisfied with what he has,” said a thin elderly man, who might have been Seneca.
“With what he is,” said Jean-Paul Sartre. For it was Sartre– Simone de Beauvoir was sitting next to him, and they were both drinking yellow cocktails the colour of sick.
“An apricot cocktail,” said Descartes, reading my thoughts. “The drink of the existentialists. Two parts gin, apricot liqueur and fresh lemon juice.”
“I want one too.”
They all turned to look at me.
“I thought you didn’t drink,” said Descartes, sliding an overly-full glass across to me.
I got my card out.
“We don’t use money here. We believe in the exchange economy.”
“What should I give you?”
“You decide.”
I took off my rose quartz bracelet and put it round his wrist.
“What’s this?” asked Descartes.
“It is what you see,” said a man who had not spoken before. “If you were a phenomenologist, you could construct a philosophy out of that bracelet. Or the apricot cocktail.”
I downed my drink in a few large gulps, as though it were lemonade. “I hate phenomenologists,” I said.
“They’ve multiplied and spread all over the place, that’s why you hate them. Anyway, hate is a form of love.”
“Are you a psychoanalyst?”
“No, I just believe all theories seem radical at the beginning. Let me introduce myself: I’m Raymond Aron.”
“Nothing’s radical anymore. You wouldn’t understand, because—”
“Don’t interrupt,” said Sartre, giving me a stern look. “I want to get to know him better.”
Simone de Beauvoir patted my hand. “He already knows him. Events are repeating themselves. But he forgets. He forgets everything, my dear little being.”
I drained my glass. “There’s the eternal return for you.”
“What do you know about the eternal return?” asked a man with a military moustache.
We formed a circle round Raymond Aron. He presented himself as a political analyst who made use of lived experience to describe the world. That was something I knew more of than any of them, simply because I happened to have been born later. Though I wasn’t quite sure that what was happening now was a “lived experience.” The man who’d been talking about God and pointing at the ceiling began explaining how the tangible world corresponded to a lower degree of reality.
Where did that leave me? Trapped in a degree of reality with curious properties: in the heart of Europe, in 2025, in the company of dead people.
“Can I ask you something? I don’t know how much longer I’ll be with you, and I want to know what’s to be done.”
Aron nudged Sartre. “Doesn’t she sound like Lenin?”
“I’ll tell you what is to be done,” said a man with a large bald spot and white tufts of hair over his ears. “Everyone is to get a dog, and love it like a fellow human being.”
“Arthur is presenting us with a metaphor for compassion,” Simone Weil whispered in my ear.
“No, not a metaphor,” said the tufted man, slapping his knees with his hands. A poodle jumped up into his lap. “I’m talking in real terms, ladies and gentlemen. Meet Atma. Everyone should get a pet.”
“I’ve got my beaver,” said Sartre, stroking de Beauvoir’s cheek.
“To take care of an animal or a person, to take responsibility,” said a woman with short grey hair, who might or might not have been Hannah Arendt.
“I’d happily take care of a woman if she looked like Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia,” said Descartes, vigorously scrubbing the bar.
Hegel joined the group. I recognised him from the black beret and the robe he wore over his clothes when he worked at home. If he’d come out like that, it meant something had shifted in the fabric of reality. Maybe the gentleman pointing at the ceiling was right, and maybe our real selves were looking down at us from on high. Maybe Dubito was my own Platonic recollection, because what I really needed right now was a grand European bar in which to deal with my emotional crisis.
They were all just like kids nobody wanted to play with, that’s why they were trying their best to dream up a future for the world. If I brought the discussion round to my thesis on the history of ethical thought in Europe, we’d turn into thinking machines. We’d miss out on our opportunity of stroking Atma’s nose and just being ordinary unambitious people drinking in a bar. The only thing I really had to say to them was that the earth turned, time was relative, and my father no longer lived.
“Can I have another apricot cocktail?”
“Right here,” said Descartes.
Translated from Greek by Jenny Steel.